Come see us at the Roswell Christkindl 11/24-12/24

Buttermilk cake with pecans on top sitting on parchment paper

Buttermilk Cake

Regular price $35.00
Unit price  per 
Shipping calculated at checkout.

AN IMPORTANT UPDATE!!!  It’s the season for cake.

Because of the overwhelming number of cake orders, we are unable to have any cakes ready until the first week of January. We are sorry if you are trying to squeeze in a last-minute treat.  


Start by imagining a moist buttermilk cake. It's difficult right? Do you know the reason why people love buttermilk pancakes? It's the same reason we made a cake out of it - It's Flaky delicious. Then add our signature blend of brown sugar pecan topping and you have the new southern tradition!

May contain: milk, eggs, tree nuts, wheat


*Everything is made in house, by hand and therefore, items may look different from the photos. Please check out our FAQ page for storage specific to your goodies!

Here at Flaky Not Flaky we use a lot of nuts and because of that, our treats are not safe for people with nut allergies.

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews
Ida M Yoshinaga
Buttermilk-y goodness with pecans and sugar

Cake was tender and surprisingly light inside, with crunchy-sweet pecans on top. The 6" one came off as delicious without feeling heavy; the buttermilk makes it moist but not weighed down. Flavors are subtle: savory, sweet, and a little tangy. Tinge of butter but not overwhelming. We would definitely get this again for ourselves or as a gift to colleagues and friends. YUM! Treat yourself.

You are amazing with words and descriptions! We couldnt have said it better ourselves and appreciate you so much as our Flaky Family!

Yummy Cake!

I highly recommend Flaky Not Flaky. From ordering to picking it up it was all easy! I ordered the buttermilk cake for Thanksgiving and everyone loved it!

Glad everyone was thrilled! This is one of Flaky's favorite things (and maybe Oprah once she has had it). Thanks for the amazing review!

Brian Bourgault
unbelievably good

We ordered a buttermilk cake 12” for Thanksgiving as well as some of the Raspberry filled Sconuts. Both were unbelievably good. The buttermilk cake was enough to feed a small army and was a welcome addition to the normal apple and pumpkin pie choices. The topping was so amazing and the cake consistency was soo good. Hard to explain, but you have to try it! The Scone-Donuts or Sconuts, were super fresh and we just let them sit out overnight and they were the perfect amount of breakfast pastry with a nice cup of Colombian coffee. I will be ordering more and more soon. Thanks Flaky Not Flaky!!

Thanks!!! Oh with coffeeeeeeeeee, yes! You know how to do it right! Thanks for being so great and for the fabulous review.